A couple long months ago I used the term “bully” in my blog post. I admitted then and again now that my definition of bully was clouded with emotion and pain from criticism I had received in an area that is extremely important in my life. Just like a teacher can mark you wrong for bubbling in answer “A” instead of “C”, a professional can tell you when you heels have crept up, when you’ve caught the horse in the mouth, etc. I felt singled out and hurt much like the feeling of being bullied… but the criticism I received was intended not for this purpose. Not to make me feel embarrassed, hurt, or to shake my confidence – although it effectively did just that. The feedback I received was intended to keep myself and our valued Zone 2 IHSA open horses happy and safe. Although I still believe the decision made on my behalf was done a little prematurely, I have to believe that it was not done from a place of intended injury. Not all people find themselves in as fortunate of a situation as myself…
I had taken a hiatus from blogging 1. because I had lost steam from my post that went “viral” increasing my view volume by 17,000+ and 2. because I was returning to my crazy hectic life as a second semester senior with important roles in two very demanding organizations + being extremely ill with the self-diagnosed plague (dramatic). However, a recent issue has come to my attention that couldn’t wait a moment longer as I write this from the upstairs silent floor at one of my school’s 3 libraries. I admit that the blog post that set the wheels in motion, was not intended for any such purpose other than to express my thoughts on a topic. I am hopeful that this blog post will do the same. I wanted to promote my situation to get advice, insight and support. I’ve received so much unexpected love and support in the last several months, I feel it’s necessary to pay it forward.
Junior Rider News – Facebook group description
Junior Rider News is a group created by junior horseback riders for junior riders. It is a place to post your latest result, photos and videos of your latest competitions.
It is also a place to post product reviews and training accomplishments. If you tried a new pair of riding gloves, tell us about it. If you finally got your horse to jump that liverpool, tell us how.
It is also a place for sponsors and college recruiters to find young talent to endorse.
We also hope to offer prizes and a year end all around rider award!
But most of all it is a place for young riders to visit, post to and enjoy!
I joined this group although I am not a junior rider (anymore) because a friend of mine shared with me that a member of the group shared my blog post here. Curiosity to view the post motivated me to join the group. Mainly the group is of people posting questions about equipment or horses, posting accomplishments and transformations, or just to meet people of similar interests. The description is super positive and most of the posts are harmless horse fun.
It’s certain posts however, that don’t seem so playful. There’s a way to express your opinion and there’s a way to put someone down… to make them feel inferior. Unfortunately I feel like riding in a way is almost designed to try to get you down… sometimes
In this sport you are judged… You are judged by your peers, by your coaches, and by the judges (the only people have really should have this power). You pay thousands of dollars for people to tell you you are a 1st place winner, or you’re not. No one would rather be in 2nd than in 1st. If that’s the case… let me know… I want to be in every one of your classes.
Even when you are not competing you are judged. Why are you using sports medicine boots, eskadron boots are much better! Or you didn’t pack your horses feet after you jumped?! How about why would you want to ride in look a like parlanti boots?! Or the you are only showing in the 3′ and you’re how old? –> These are just a few things I’ve heard personally. To be honest, these statements above have bothered me at some point in my life. At the age of 21, I have DEFINITELY become a lot tougher about any and all things, including criticism or just statements that have no merit. It doesn’t mean I don’t think about them or that they didn’t bother me…
After all my time blogging, I’ve only received a handful of negative comments. Some of them I’m assuming coming from people who see my situation VASTLY different than how I see it. Just like I hope people respect my perspective, I respect that people have their own view points and I can’t fault them for that.
A most recent situation that stemmed from Junior Rider News and then onto other media sites primarily Facebook and Twitter has captured my attention. Jackie Debus, a long islander rider, posted a photo of herself jumping on a post “What’s the highest you’ve jumped?” as a comment on JRN. Her post was obviously being read on a phone and was screen-shotted and uploaded to a decently well known anon twitter account with a comment questioning the legitimacy in the height of the jump.
The post reads “usually I ignore posts where the height someone claims a jump is doesn’t seem right… But this one I couldn’t even” – I’m not even exactly sure what the height of the jump is in my defense. Some times I go to horse shows where the jump is in front of my nose and I question if it’s true to height. Especially when you are evaluating a jump from a photo, there are lots of variables that are unknown between the angle of the shot, the height of the standard… the list continues.
This is not the first time people have been “called out” in photos. A similar incidence happened a few years back where a Facebook user was using pictures of different bay horses jumping and claiming them to be all the same horse and all HER horse – both untrue statements. Another user used photos of another user jumping at a competition, and claimed them to be herself. Another twitter user claimed a photo to be her new jumper – Sapphire MCLAIN WARD’s horse – which was almost comical…
Unfortunately for Jackie, all social media sights are public forums. And there are a lot of online equestrian forums too that are all public. Once you put something on the internet, it’s fair game to all. That being said, I wouldn’t appreciate someone using my photo or words without my permission, but there’s not much you can do about it. I would admit that I don’t usually ask people if I can release a photo of them on my blog if they are mentioned. I usually know the person well enough to find a flattering photo of them on their facebook. I really only ask permission to quote people – which I asked Jackie prior to writing this article. I attempted to reach out to the twitter account “ShitTrainersSay” – but was unable to message them via Twitter because they were not following my account.
I have seen countless screenshots of conversations back and forth between Jackie and this anon, and the anon and other anons, and Jackie and people on facebook…
I’m not going to give “My Take On the Situation” in this blog. I have a lot of views on the things that pertain to me and I’m not going to pretend that this is one of those things. However I did want to bring to light what social media and online forums can do…
Language is an expressive medium. Between tone and inflection and gestures we can say much more than just what we are saying. However, written language like you see on your computer screen has its faults. It’s extremely difficult to convey mood and tone over written words. A talented few authors can do it, but those aren’t usually the people on twitter and facebook and online forums. To play devil’s advocate I am always the first to say “they didn’t mean it like that”. Then again, sometimes you can EASILY read between the lines.
My hope to all Anon accounts, and to everyone using public media is that everyone chooses their words with the upmost care and to understand that as hard as you try, you may be misunderstood. I would hope that people would stop and think “what would i say if that was posted about me” just to put yourself in the shoes of the receiving end.
I am sorry not to be able to give a more one-sided opinion on the situation and I am definitely not one to play Switzerland. But after seeing all the posts (and being exhausted by the sarcasm) I really am at a loss. My only hope is that eventually social media and public forums will just stick to their purposes – connecting people positively instead of negatively. I have met and interacted with so many great people because of it, so I would encourage anyone in a similar situation like Jackie and the anon ShitTrainersSay to just shake it off and chalk it up to the few pits that online media has to offer.
As far as the photo goes – again I really couldn’t tell you what the “true height” is. And everyone has their own opinions. As far as messaging someone to take a photo down of you – I say to kill the person with kindness to get what you want is probably a great strategy. Being on the defensive will only get you so far, but maybe you have every right to be defensive! Twitter conversations are viewable to the public. The word psycho is strong and the word bully is stronger. Everyone has their own perspective – disagree with it sure, but disrespecting it is another thing entirely. We get most upset about the things that mean a lot to us. Jumping 4’3″ or 2’6″ on a horse you trained yourself, or a school master maybe the greatest accomplishment you’ve had to date – having someone chip away at that isn’t a great feeling –> but that accomplishment is for you and no one else…
I’m happy to be over the plague and back on my writing grind! Stay tuned, don’t think I’ve forgotten I am scheduled to horse show in 10 days!